The exponential series
The starting point of the proof is the series expansion of e, obtained by evaluating the exponential series at 1:
e=k=0∑+∞k!1=1+1+21+61+241+1201+⋯
Convergence is very fast. Let us denote the partial sums and the remainder:
Sn=k=0∑nk!1andRn=e−Sn=k=n+1∑+∞k!1
| n |
Sn |
e−Sn |
| 2 |
25=2.5 |
≈2.18×10−1 |
| 4 |
2465≈2.70833 |
≈9.95×10−3 |
| 6 |
7201957≈2.71806 |
≈2.26×10−4 |
| 10 |
≈2.7182818 |
≈2.73×10−8 |
The decisive bound on the remainder
The whole proof rests on the following inequality, valid for n≥1:
0<Rn<n⋅n!1
Lower bound. All the terms of Rn are strictly positive, so Rn>0.
Upper bound. Factor out the first term:
Rn=(n+1)!1(1+n+21+(n+2)(n+3)1+⋯)
Each factor n+j1 is strictly less than n+11 as soon as j≥2, so the parenthesis is bounded above by the geometric series with ratio n+11:
Rn<(n+1)!1j=0∑+∞(n+1)j1=(n+1)!1⋅nn+1=n⋅n!1
Why this bound is the right one
Multiply the inequality by n!:
0<n!Rn<n1
The quantity n!Rn is therefore squeezed strictly between 0 and n1, that is, strictly between 0 and 1 as soon as n≥2. It will be enough to prove that this number is an integer to reach the contradiction: that is exactly the program of the next chapter.
Classic pitfall
Confusing n⋅n!1 with (n+1)!1, or settling for the crude bound Rn<(n+1)!1⋅(n+1)=n!1. The latter gives 0<n!Rn<1, which is in fact also enough for the contradiction; the version with n⋅n!1 is simply sharper.